Intolerância, intolerante, intolerável: uma análise retórica do discurso de gramáticos e linguistas

Abstract

The speeches of Brazilian grammarians and linguists have proven ineffective in achieving their goals, namely that Brazilian conclude school as a competent reader and producer of texts, acting as a citizen and proud of his/her linguistic identity. Although the two groups engage in the study of language, both are configured as adversaries, presenting, relative to one another, a violent and intolerant discourse, with the presence of disqualification, insults and generalizations in relation to other group's speech. This work intends, through rhetorical analysis, not only to bring up some discursive marks of this unproductive conflict, but also to raise a discursive reflection on other possible ways - to make this conflict productive. To meet this goal, we used texts that talk about conflict in general, on the conflict between these two groups as well we used texts that carry some of the the marks of the conflict. Some of the authors present in the analysis: Carlos Alberto Faraco, Diana Luz Pessoa de Barros, Djane Antonucci Correa, Jeni Silva Turazza, Luiz Antonio Ferreira, Luiz Carlos Travaglia, Marcos Bagno, Maria Helena de Moura Neves, Marli Quadros Leite, Napoleão Mendes de Almeida, Neusa Barbosa Bastos, Pasquale Cipro Neto